Burns and the head of Israel’s Mossad intelligence service, David Barnea, will meet with Qatari Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani in Europe this weekend.
By TOVAH LAZAROFF
JANUARY 25, 2024 18:36
Updated: JANUARY 25, 2024 21:34

 

 Director of Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) William Burns speaks in Washington, US March 8, 2022 (photo credit: REUTERS/EVELYN HOCKSTEIN)

Director of Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) William Burns speaks in Washington, US March 8, 2022 (photo credit: REUTERS/EVELYN HOCKSTEIN)
Director of Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) William Burns speaks in Washington, US March 8, 2022
(photo credit: REUTERS/EVELYN HOCKSTEIN)

The public spat between Jerusalem and Doha has not prevented US Central Intelligence Agency Director William Burns from heading to Europe to hold talks with Israeli, Egyptian, and Qatari officials in the coming days.

Both Reuters and The Washington Post reported on Burn’s meeting as Israel’s war cabinet met on Thursday night to discuss the hostages as Qatar and the relatives of the hostages accused Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of harming the possibility of a potential deal.

Israel has proposed a two-month pause in fighting to allow for the phased release of the 136 hostages still being held following the Hamas-led October 7 attack, The Washington Post said.

Biden administration working on new hostage deal
Burns “has been…involved in helping us with the hostage deal that was in place and trying to help us pursue another one,” White House National Security Council spokesman John Kirby told reporters traveling with US President Joe Biden aboard Air Force One, referring specific questions to the agency.

“The discussions we are having about trying to get a renewed hostage deal are sober and serious,” Kirby said, recalling that US special envoy Brett McGurk was in the region to try and push forward a deal.

The Israeli people want their “loved ones back,” and the US wants its hostages back home, Kirby said, explaining that “there is a lot of energy being put into this across the region with our Israeli counterparts as well as other counterparts including the Qataris.”

Israelis gather in Tel Aviv for the release of Gaza hostages on November 25, 2023 (credit: AVSHALOM SASSONI/MAARIV)Enlrage image
Israelis gather in Tel Aviv for the release of Gaza hostages on November 25, 2023 (credit: AVSHALOM SASSONI/MAARIV)
The CIA, which has a policy of not disclosing the director’s travel, declined to comment on the meeting in Europe next week.

US President Joe Biden dispatched Burns to speak with officials, including Qatari Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani, comes as Israel’s retaliatory military campaign against Hamas continues into its fourth month.

Netanyahu ‘stoking tensions’ with Qatar
The families’ campaign to free the hostages accused Netanyahu or his associates on Thursday of intentionally stoking tensions with Qatar by leaking a tape in which Netanyahu insulted Doha’s efforts to negotiate a deal.

“All conversations that take place in meetings with the Prime Minister are recorded by his office and his associates present at the meeting,” the campaign’s spokesperson Haim Rubinstein said.

“The families participating in the meeting had their phones taken at the entrance,” Rubinstein explained.

“The decision whether to leak information concerning the deal and its intermediaries is the Prime Minister’s office,” Rubinstein stated.

He spoke in response to a story on Channel 12, which featured a leaked recording from the closed-door meeting held with the family earlier this week in which Netanyahu could be heard referring to Qatar as a “problematic mediator.”

Rubinstein said that “the fact that the censorship permitted publication of the [tape] is serious and indicates a loss of judgment. The cabinet’s duty is to prevent a crisis that would endanger the lives of the captives.”

The decision not to censor the publication of the tape and thus “endanger the lives of the hostages” after they were already abandoned on October 7 is a crime!” he said.

“We demand that the members of the cabinet stop the madness and act responsibly to save the lives of 136 Israelis who were abandoned and kidnapped,” he stated.

Rubinstein charged that “an organized campaign is underway against them with one goal: to delegitimize the hostages who are in the hands of the monsters of Hamas!”

He spoke up after Qatar called Netanyahu’s comments “irresponsible” and said they were harming efforts to mediate a deal to release the captives.

The Prime Minister’s Office said it did “not record, approve or distribute the recordings, and any other claim is false.”

Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich publicly backed Netanyahu by attacking Qatar in a post on X, in which he charged that it was a “country that supports terrorism and finances terrorism.”

Qatar “is Hamas’ patron and is largely responsible for the massacre committed by Hamas of Israeli citizens.

“The West’s attitude towards it is hypocritical and based on improper economic interests. The West can and should exert much stronger levers on her and bring about the release of the abductees immediately,” he said.

“One thing is clear,” Smotrich said, “Qatar will not be involved in what happened in Gaza the day after the war.”

He expanded on those comments at a conference by the non-governmental group the Bitchonistim.

Qatar is playing a double game with the West because it encourages, assists, and finances terrorism, Smotrich stated.

“Today, Qatar is the element that is the most delaying the return of the Israeli captives,” Smotrich said. “We could receive the 136 Israeli captives tomorrow morning If Qatar issues an unequivocal ultimatum to Hamas,” he added.

“Qatar has a clear interest in preserving Hamas, ensuring its survival and continued governance in Gaza,” and as such, it has done everything to thwart Israel’s efforts to destroy the terror group, Smotrich stated.

The hostages are a bargaining chip to help Hamas remain in power in Gaza, he said, and the terror group will not relinquish them so easily, he said.

Israel must cut its ties to Qatar, Smotrich stated. It’s time to tell the hostages that not all the hostages can be freed, he said. It’s a mistake to think that Hamas leader Yehyeh Sinwar “will give up such a valuable asset (the hostage)” because by holding on to them, he weakens Israeli society and tears it apart, Smotrich said..

US State Department deputy spokesperson Vedant Petal said that Qatar remains a key US ally.

The animosity between Israel and Qatar, which do not have diplomatic relations, comes amid increased tensions between Israel and its Middle East ally Egypt, with whom it has had formal relations since 1979.

At issue in particular has been Israel’s insistence that to prevent arms smuggling into Gaza, it must control a buffer zone in the enclave by the Egyptian border, known as the Philadelphi corridor.

Egypt’s President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi on Wednesday accused Israel of holding up aid deliveries for the Gaza Strip as a pressure tactic to push Hamas to free the hostages.

“This is a form of pressure on the Gaza Strip and its people over the conflict and the release of hostages. They are using this as a pressure tool on the people of the Strip,” Sisi said in comments to mark Egypt’s national police day.

Israel denied the charge. “Our inspection process is efficient, with us scaling up our capacities to maximize inspection capabilities,” COGAT, an Israeli Defence Ministry agency that coordinates aid deliveries with the United Nations and humanitarian groups, said on social media platform X on Wednesday.

“There is no limit to the amount of aid that can enter Gaza.”

Earlier this week, government spokesperson Eylon Levy said that trucks entering Gaza had the capacity to carry more than what the international community had sent for Gaza.


ICJ to rule Friday on whether to order an end to the Gaza war

The ruling on provisional measures is preliminary, as the ICJ has yet to hold hearings on the actual genocide charge, which Israel rejects.

 Judges at the ICJ hear a request for emergency measures by South Africa, who asked the court to order Israel to stop its military actions in Gaza, in The Hague, Netherlands, january 11, 2024. (photo credit: REUTERS/THILO SCHMUELGEN)
Judges at the ICJ hear a request for emergency measures by South Africa, who asked the court to order Israel to stop its military actions in Gaza, in The Hague, Netherlands, january 11, 2024.
(photo credit: REUTERS/THILO SCHMUELGEN)
The International Court of Justice (ICJ) plans to issue its ruling on South Africa’s request that it order Israel to stop its war in Gaza in open court on Friday at 1 p.m. (2 p.m. Israel time) at The Hague, Netherlands.

South Africa’s News24 said Pretoria government officials had arrived in the Netherlands in for the judgment.

The ICJ held hearings earlier this month on South Africa’s plea to issue provisional measures related to its charges before the court that Israel was guilty of genocide in Gaza.

The ruling on provisional measures is preliminary, as the ICJ has yet to hold hearings on the actual genocide charge, which Israel has rejected outright.

ISRAEL FOREIGN MINISTRY legal adviser Tal Becker and British barrister Malcolm Shaw KC, who appeared on behalf of Israel, attend the International Court of Justice hearing, in The Hague on Friday. (credit: THILO SCHMUELGEN/REUTERS)Enlrage image
ISRAEL FOREIGN MINISTRY legal adviser Tal Becker and British barrister Malcolm Shaw KC, who appeared on behalf of Israel, attend the International Court of Justice hearing, in The Hague on Friday. (credit: THILO SCHMUELGEN/REUTERS)

In its reply to South Africa’s plea, Israel refuted the genocide allegations, delaring them to be “grossly distorted,” adding that it had the right to defend itself and was targeting Hamas, which had attacked its on October 7, killing over 1,200 people and seizing some 250 hostages, and not Palestinian civilians.

The ruling comes at a critical junction in hostage release negotiations

The ruling will be delivered as Israel is under intense international pressure to halt the war in Gaza while it is in talks over a hostage deal to secure the release of the remaining 132 captives held there in exchange for at least a month-long pause in the war.

Israel has been under tight scrutiny due to the high death toll in Gaza, with Hamas asserting that over 25,000 Palestinians have been killed in war-related fighting in Gaza. Israel has said that at least 9,000 of those killed were combatants.

South Africa’s foreign minister, Naledi Pandor, will be present in The Hague to attend the ruling, a South African government spokesperson said in a post on X.

 

Reuters contributed to this report.


Senior Hamas official Sami Abu Zuhri told Reuters on Monday the organization was open to discussing ideas but that no deal was yet in place.

 An IDF Paratroopers Brigade soldier operates in the Gaza Strip, earlier this month. (photo credit: OREN BEN HAKOON/FLASH90)
An IDF Paratroopers Brigade soldier operates in the Gaza Strip, earlier this month.
(photo credit: OREN BEN HAKOON/FLASH90)
Defense Minister Yoav Gallant blamed Hamas’s leadership abroad for thwarting a hostage deal by taking a hardline stance, as KAN News reported that the terror group had rejected the latest Israeli initiative.

“I am now hearing the beginning of all kinds of announcements on behalf of all kinds of Hamas officials, who are talking about hostage deals, as a result of their contacts in Egypt and Qatar,” Gallant told soldiers during a visit down south.

He charged that “the most extreme people in the Hamas negotiations are the ones who are the furthest away from the Gaza Strip, those who fly in luxury planes [and] sit in luxury hotels.”

“Those who suffer in Gaza and are constantly under your tanks’ chains are not such heroes. I hear what they say; most of them want to stop” fighting, Gallant said.

Reuters had raised hopes of progress on a deal with its report on Wednesday morning that Israel and Hamas broadly agree in principle that an exchange of Israeli hostages for Palestinian prisoners could take place during a month-long ceasefire, but the framework plan is being held up by the two sides’ differences over how to bring a permanent end to the Gaza war.

 Defense Minister Yoav Gallant flies above the skies of Gaza with the Israeli Air Force, January 21, 2024 (credit: DEFENSE MINISTRY)Enlrage image
Defense Minister Yoav Gallant flies above the skies of Gaza with the Israeli Air Force, January 21, 2024 (credit: DEFENSE MINISTRY)

Hamas has insisted that any deal must include a permanent ceasefire, while Israel has stood on its principled position that the war can only end when the terror group is ousted from the enclave.

KAN said that Hamas, in rejecting the latest proposal, had wanted the IDF to fully withdraw from Gaza in the first stage of the deal. Many of the proposals have included phased releases of the 132 hostages still held in Gaza.

On the American Front

US National Security Council spokesperson John Kirby told reporters in Washington on Wednesday that special envoy Brett McGurk was in Doha to discuss a hostage deal. Qatar and Egypt have acted as mediators between Hamas and Israel on the issue.

“Brett is in the region right now; this is top of his agenda. He is in Doha today,” Kirby said.

“These are very sober and serious discussions we are having. We certainly want another humanitarian pause so we can get aid in and hostages out,” he stated.

The US has supported Israel’s military goal and has stated publicly that it does not believe there should be a ceasefire until Hamas is defeated.

At the Knesset, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said that this “is a war for our home. It must end – and it will end – with the defeat of the aggression and evil of the new Nazis.

“Anyone who participated took hostages, and raped and murdered our citizens brought unprecedented destruction on themselves,” Netanyahu said.

“There is not, nor will there be, any compromise about safeguarding our existence and our future for generations to come,” he stressed.

THE LATEST round of shuttle diplomacy started on Dec. 28 and has narrowed disagreements about the length of an initial ceasefire to around 30 days, said one of the sources, an official briefed on the negotiations. Hamas had first proposed a pause of several months.

However, Hamas has since refused to move forward with the plans until the future conditions of a permanent ceasefire are agreed upon, according to six sources. Most of the sources consulted for this story requested anonymity in order to speak freely about sensitive matters.

WHILE ISRAEL has sought to negotiate one stage at a time, Hamas is seeking “a package deal” in which there would be a permanent ceasefire before hostages are released during the initial phase, said one of the sources, a Palestinian official close to the mediation efforts. Israel and Hamas are speaking through the mediators rather than talking directly.

Two Egyptian security sources said that there was work underway to convince Hamas to accept a one-month truce, to be followed by a permanent ceasefire. However, in order to agree to the initial truce, Hamas is requesting guarantees that the second phase of the deal will be carried out, the sources said.

The sources did not provide details regarding what such guarantees might consist of.

Asked about the negotiations, senior Hamas official Sami Abu Zuhri told Reuters on Monday that the organization was open to discussing ideas but that no deal was yet in place.

“We are open to all initiatives and proposals, but any agreement must be based on ending the aggression and the occupation’s complete pullout from the Gaza Strip,” said Abu Zuhri.

One offer by Israel is to end the war if Hamas removes six senior leaders from Gaza, said a seventh source, a senior Hamas official. However, Hamas “absolutely” rejected the proposal, he said.

The source said the list included the masterminds of Hamas’s Oct. 7 attacks on Israel, Yahya Sinwar and Mohamed al-Deif, who are Israel’s top targets to kill or capture and are thought to be hiding deep within the terror group’s extensive network of tunnels beneath Gaza.

Qatar said it was appalled that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called them “problematic mediators,” in a conversation he held with relatives of the hostages held in Gaza.

“We are appalled by the alleged remarks attributed to the Israeli Prime Minister in various media reports about Qatar’s mediation role,” Qatar Foreign Ministry spokesman Majed Al-Ansari wrote in a post on X.

“These remarks if validated, are irresponsible and destructive to the efforts to save innocent lives, but are not surprising,” he said.

Ansari accused Netanyahu of undermining the mediation.

 “If the reported remarks are found to be true, the Israeli Prime Minister would only be obstructing and undermining the mediation process, for reasons that appear to serve his political career instead of prioritizing saving innocent lives, including Israeli hostages,” Ansari said.

 “Instead of concerning himself with Qatar’s strategic relations with the United States, we hope Netanyahu decides to operate in good faith and concentrate on the release of the hostages,” he said.

The comments were said during a private meeting that was taped. That tape was then leaked to Channel 12, which published Netanyahu’s remarks on Tuesday night.

Qatar and Egypt have been mediating a potential second hostage deal for the remaining 132 captives, out of the 253 that Hamas seized during its October 7 cross-border massacre attack against Israel.

During a November deal mediated by Qatar and Egypt, 105 were freed. The IDF returned eleven bodies of the captives from Gaza.

Answer said that “for months, and following a successful mediation last year that led to the release of more than a hundred hostages, Qatar has been engaged in regular dialogue with the negotiating parties including Israeli institutions, attempting to establish the framework for a new hostage agreement and the immediate entry of humanitarian aid into Gaza.”

British Foreign Security David Cameron, who visited Israel on Wednesday and met with Netanyahu and Foreign Minister Israel Katz, wrote in a post on X that he focused on three goals during his visit: securing the immediate release of the hostages, increasing aid to Gaza and ensuring an immediate humanitarian pause, as well as the movement toward a permanent ceasefire.

He is expected to also visit Qatar during his trip to the region.

Reuters contributed to this report.